Chris Cook

If you were writing an economists’ manifesto, regional payscales would be one of the few items on which most agreed. The principle is pretty simple: why should a teacher be paid a king’s ransom in Southport, but starved in Southwark.

Part of the principle of this idea is that it is difficult to recruit in areas of high “outside” wages, if you have a national pay-scale. Conversely, the theory goes, when the state “overpays”, it can price out local enterprise.

Some economists from the Centre for Economic Performance at the LSE found a scary natural experiment to test this idea: survival rates from heart attacks.

We predict that areas with higher outside wages should suffer from problems of recruiting, retaining and motivating high quality workers and this should harm hospital performance. We construct hospital-level panel data on both quality – as measured by death rates (within hospital deaths within thirty days of emergency admission for acute myocardial infarction, AMI) – and productivity. We present evidence that stronger local labor markets significantly worsen hospital outcomes in terms of quality and productivity.

A 10 per cent increase in the outside wage is associated with a 4% to 8% increase in AMI death rates. We find that an important part of this effect operates through hospitals in high outside wage areas having to rely more on temporary “agency staff” as they are unable to increase (regulated) wages in order to attract permanent employees.

Emily Cadman

The latest World Health Organisation statistics report has thrown a light on the unglamorous but essential backbone of health policy – accurate death reporting.

According to the report, currently only 15 percent of the world’s population lives in a country where more than 90 percent of births and deaths are registered – and unsurprisingly most of these 34 countries are in Europe and the Americas.

It’s not surprising that war torn countries like Afghanistan might have had other concerns than registration data. But the list of countries without comprehensive data include major economic and population centres like China and India – both of whom use sample registration approaches. The full country by country list is on this pdf.

WHO regionNo death registration
data
Low qualityMedium qualityHigh qualityNumber of WHO
Member States
AFR42 21146
AMR27131335
SEAR7 40011
EUR2 11241653
EMR9 102021
WPR1247427
Global74 384734193

The rapid growth in greener, more fuel efficient vehicles will leave the Treasury with a £13bn shortfall in motoring taxes by the end of next decade, despite an anticipated 44 per cent jump in traffic.

The predictions from the Institute for Fiscal Studies, an independent think tank, are based on an analysis of the government’s own long-term forecasts, which show that by 2029 fuel duty will contribute 1.1 per cent of GDP, down from 1.7 per cent today. Vehicle excise duty will drop to 0.1 per cent from 0.3 per cent.

Receipts from the taxes total £38bn a year, equivalent to 7 per cent of all Treasury income.

The lost revenue is equivalent to increasing the basic rate of income tax from 20p to 23.4p, VAT from 20 per cent to 22.7 per cent or raising fuel duty by more than 50 per cent, according to the IFS report, published today.

Chris Cook

Earlier, I wrote a blogpost on the EEF’s interesting finding about 446 schools where the average of poorer pupils’ exam results were better than the national average for all children. Those schools certainly repay attention. As a first stab at this, there is one trend that becomes apparent from looking at their locations. One English region stands out:

RegionComprehensivesHigh performers on EEF measure
North West39952
London383164
South East36856
West Midlands33039
East of England30148
Yorkshire and the Humber28217
South West26229
East Midlands23030
North East15211

Chris Cook

There has been a curious outbreak of maths in education policy discussion this week. This all started a fortnight ago when Kevan Collins, chief executive of the Education Endowment Foundation, put together a really interesting set of numbers in the TES.

He identified 446 schools where poor children, defined as those eligible for free school meals (FSM), were beating the national average for all children. This is a real core of excellent schools who are market-beaters, and excludes grammar schools. (For people who want to replicate the results in Stata, the necessary file is here.)

Here’s how that population of children within those 440 schools look like, alongside the whole school system graph, on what one civil servant affectionately calls my “Graph of Doom“ for 2010-11:

These are average GCSE points attained by each child – 8 points for an A* down to 1 point for a G. Poorest children, defined by the multiple deprivation score for their postcodes, are at left. Richest are at right. Zero on the y-axis is the national average (37.3 pts) and the units are standard deviations (22.0 pts).

Immigration has helped to raise average wages of most UK-born workers but held back wage growth for those at the most poorly paid end of the labour market, new study has shown.

Research published in the Review of Economic Studies examined the period between 1997 and 2005, when there was an increase in the foreign-born population equal to 3 per cent of the native population.

The authors – economists Christian Dustmann, Tommaso Frattini and Ian Preston – estimate that immigration depressed wages by 0.7p per hour at the 10th percentile, or the bottom layer, of UK-born workers.

But immigration contributed about 1.5p per hour to wage growth at the median and slightly more than 2p per hour at the 90th percentile.

Schools taking part in the government’s flagship academies programme are being overpaid by more than £120m this academic year owing to errors by the Department for Education, an investigation by the Financial Times has revealed.

The majority of the overspend will be clawed back from local authorities, stoking concerns that schools participating in the converter academies scheme are being favoured over other state schools.

Currently seen as the government’s most visible public policy success, if local authority schools opt to become an academy, they are funded directly by the DfE rather than via local authorities. They gain autonomy over pay and curriculum, but are supposed to receive equivalent funding.

However, analysis of DfE data reveals that 90 per cent of England’s 1,421 converter academy schools are being overpaid, with the bulk of the errors coming from schools which converted in the previous academic year.

Martin Stabe

What we’re reading today in the world of statistics, open data and data journalism:

We like a good political choropleth around here, and Sunday’s European election extravaganza did not disappoint in the psephological cartography department.

A good map of the Greek results can be found at igraphics.gr, Le Monde has the obligatory map of the French presidential election par département, and Michael Neutze’s site Wahlatlas covered the results in the German state of Schleswig-Holstein.

The House of Lords authorities are refusing to hand over officials’ estimates of how much it will cost taxpayers to replace the chamber with a mostly elected senate, prompting anger from Tory politicians.

Officials have rejected a freedom of information request by the Financial Times, saying that the relevant information was produced “solely” for the joint committee on Lords reform. “A decision was taken by them not to publish it as part of their report,” they said in their response.

David Davis, MP for Haltemprice and Howden, said there was a “clear-cut case” for the cost estimates to be put in the public domain.

Emily Cadman

What we’re reading today in the world of statistics, open data and data journalism:

It’s results day in the  UK for local and mayoral elections, which means there are a number of interesting election related posts.  As the debate in the studios continue as to the effect the poor weather had on voter turnout, the Guardian’s Polly Curtis rounds up the evidence.

Chris Prosser at Oxford University takes a look at the ongoing question of whether local election results can be used to predict general election results – the conclusion yes, but there are some big buts.

In a more light-hearted vein, this post from Ipos Mori’s director of political analysis Dr Roger Mortimore on his tongue in cheek FA Cup election prediction model.

The key quote comes at the end

Too much that passes that for political analysis these days, especially on the Internet, is entirely dependent on reading deep significance into coincidental associations between events. Unless you know why they coincide, that there really is a causal link between the two, such associations may well be meaningless.

Entirely coincidentally, Flowing Data takes a look at the role of commonsense in statistics and common statistical fallacies, linking to an interesting research paper on how students learn statistics, emphasising the importance of teaching critical thinking not just  mathematical knowledge.

FT data

on statistics

About this blog Blog guide

FT data is a collaborative effort from journalists across the FT working in data journalism, statistics and data visualisation.

We aim to look at statistical issues in depth and provide original analysis of data. Occasionally we’ll also post guest contributions. Get in touch at ftdata@ft.com

To comment, please register for free with FT.com and read our policy on submitting comments.

All posts are published in UK time.

E-mail ftdata@ft.com

See the full list of FT blogs.

Data sources

Economic calendar

Global coverage of leading economic reports and events

Data archive

Ready access to the FT's extensive history of markets data tables

The authors

Chris Cook is the FT's education correspondent. After joining the FT in 2008 as a Peter Martin Fellow, he worked for two years as a leader writer.



Emily Cadman joined the FT in 2010 and is head of the interactive desk.



Martin Stabe works on the FT's interactive team, specialising in databases for interactive graphics.



Keith Fray heads the editorial statistics team, providing data for articles and graphics. His background is in economics, studying at Birkbeck College, London.

Sally Gainsbury works in the investigations team in London, specialising in public policy and data analysis.